Thanks for the replies!
As an update, after discovering the hard way that there is no longer a ThreeSixty in the Landmark I made my way over to Oscar's, which had Paul's organic "full cream", which is like milk with the cream globules still floating in it. I'm trying it now and it's pretty tasty after you get over the fact that there are little bits of butter floating in your coffee.
I happened to walk by a store on Peel street - Hershey's Caffeteria I think - which had tons of coffee brewing equipment for sale. It's a bit pricey but I'm probably going to cave since its so convenient. They also had hand grinders, and probably have a solid selection of coffee beans. I may wait until this week so I can check out Rabbithole, which was closed but looks like it probably has everything I need.