Like Tree145Likes

Alice Wu - SCMP

Closed Thread
Page 1 of 31 1 2 3 4 9 ... LastLast
  1. #1

    Join Date
    Oct 2006
    Location
    Hong Kong
    Posts
    15,557

    Alice Wu - SCMP

    Just amazing.

    http://www.scmp.com/comment/insight-...age=1#comments


  2. #2

    Join Date
    Mar 2013
    Posts
    2,454

    Absolutely ridiculous. And she claims to be a political consultant from UCLA?


  3. #3

    Join Date
    Dec 2012
    Posts
    904

    Can somebody copy-paste the article?


  4. #4

    Join Date
    Nov 2007
    Location
    Wanchai
    Posts
    5,063

    Here you go

    It has been three years since the Manila hostage crisis, yet survivors and victims' families still wait for the justice they deserve, and so the Philippines remains "black" on the Hong Kong government's travel alert list. Some see it as nonsensical, since the travel alert has done little to get the Philippine government to budge. Certainly, it has proved ineffective.

    Sure, the new Manila mayor (and the country's ex-president) Joseph Estrada apologised for the tragedy last week. But it's puzzling since the apology wasn't his to make. Whether it was sincere is irrelevant. All Estrada can be sorry for is his president's and his predecessor's inability to say sorry.

    Estrada must know that his apology is technically inconsequential. And while all this talk about what he would have done may well be true, it has the additional "virtue" of being self-serving; highlighting where Alfredo Lim failed and how he would have handled it better is a terrific public relations move. It was a perfect image-building opportunity and Estrada capitalised on it.

    The apology should have no effect on Hong Kong's travel alert, which really shouldn't be much of a cause for controversy. Over 100,000 Hong Kong tourists visit the Philippines every year, even after August 23, 2010. So, it is clear it hasn't deterred Hongkongers from visiting a country whose authorities have proved - in their handling of the hostage crisis - to be completely inept and incapable of protecting innocent lives in hostage situations. Every year, enough Hongkongers choose to look past this gross negligence and gross incompetence.

    Sure, the actions of key players who could have ensured a much better outcome on that tragic day have been criticised. But that's little reason to assume steps have been taken to better protect tourists. There are risks associated with travelling to the Philippines; travel warnings have been issued by other countries, for reasons like "increased terrorism activity".

    The four basic demands of the survivors and relatives of victims remain unanswered: an official apology by the Philippine government; compensation; punishment for the officials responsible; and, improved tourist safety. And as they press on with legal action, the least the Hong Kong government can do is keep the travel alert.

    The treatment by the Philippine government of the fatal shooting of Taiwanese fisherman Hung Shih-cheng by the Philippine coastguard in May stands in stark contrast to its silence on the hostage crisis. In that case, the Philippines issued a formal apology, agreed to pay compensation to Hung's family, and homicide charges have been recommended - and it took less than three months following the incident for these to happen.

    We're not blind to the geopolitics that makes Hong Kong's three-year-old tragedy different from that of the Taiwanese fisherman's. It may seem nonsensical that politics should stand in the way of human lives. Call it nonsensically necessary if you want, but without the victims' demands answered, the travel alert remains. Removing it would not be politically viable

  5. #5

    Join Date
    Mar 2013
    Posts
    2,454

    Hong Kong is right to keep black travel alert on the Philippines

    Alice Wu says the travel alert on the Philippines should stay until victims of the Manila hostage crisis get the justice they deserveAlice Wu

    It has been three years since the Manila hostage crisis, yet survivors and victims' families still wait for the justice they deserve, and so the Philippines remains "black" on the Hong Kong government's travel alert list. Some see it as nonsensical, since the travel alert has done little to get the Philippine government to budge. Certainly, it has proved ineffective.

    Sure, the new Manila mayor (and the country's ex-president) Joseph Estrada apologised for the tragedy last week. But it's puzzling since the apology wasn't his to make.

    Whether it was sincere is irrelevant. All Estrada can be sorry for is his president's and his predecessor's inability to say sorry.Estrada must know that his apology is technically inconsequential. And while all this talk about what he would have done may well be true, it has the additional "virtue" of being self-serving; highlighting where Alfredo Lim failed and how he would have handled it better is a terrific public relations move. It was a perfect image-building opportunity and Estrada capitalised on it.

    The apology should have no effect on Hong Kong's travel alert, which really shouldn't be much of a cause for controversy. Over 100,000 Hong Kong tourists visit the Philippines every year, even after August 23, 2010. So, it is clear it hasn't deterred Hongkongers from visiting a country whose authorities have proved - in their handling of the hostage crisis - to be completely inept and incapable of protecting innocent lives in hostage situations. Every year, enough Hongkongers choose to look past this gross negligence and gross incompetence.

    Sure, the actions of key players who could have ensured a much better outcome on that tragic day have been criticised. But that's little reason to assume steps have been taken to better protect tourists. There are risks associated with travelling to the Philippines; travel warnings have been issued by other countries, for reasons like "increased terrorism activity".The four basic demands of the survivors and relatives of victims remain unanswered: an official apology by the Philippine government; compensation; punishment for the officials responsible; and, improved tourist safety. And as they press on with legal action, the least the Hong Kong government can do is keep the travel alert.

    The treatment by the Philippine government of the fatal shooting of Taiwanese fisherman Hung Shih-cheng by the Philippine coastguard in May stands in stark contrast to its silence on the hostage crisis. In that case, the Philippines issued a formal apology, agreed to pay compensation to Hung's family, and homicide charges have been recommended - and it took less than three months following the incident for these to happen.

    We're not blind to the geopolitics that makes Hong Kong's three-year-old tragedy different from that of the Taiwanese fisherman's. It may seem nonsensical that politics should stand in the way of human lives. Call it nonsensically necessary if you want, but without the victims' demands answered, the travel alert remains. Removing it would not be politically viable.

    Alice Wu is a political consultant and a former associate director of the Asia Pacific Media Network at UCLA


  6. #6

  7. #7

    Join Date
    Jun 2011
    Posts
    5,110
    Quote Originally Posted by usehername:
    Absolutely ridiculous. And she claims to be a political consultant from UCLA?
    Which part is ridiculous precisely? The part about being ok with keeping the black travel alert as political retribution by HK (not that it is having much impact on travelers)? Or the part where the Philippine government is giving a middle finger to the victims because Manila can afford to ignore us?

    Fact is, using policies (such as travel alerts) as political weapons is hardly unique to HK. Only the naive would think otherwise. The HK gov can claim they are doing "something" by upholding the travel alert when in fact they have done very little for the victims. Likewise, the Manila government, for their own political ends, don't apologize because they feel no pressure to do so.
    Last edited by Watercooler; 26-08-2013 at 05:21 PM.
    Titus and cheepo like this.

  8. #8

    Join Date
    Aug 2005
    Posts
    1,960

    Rather silly to keep this black alert as it really abuses and confuses the meaning of what a black alert is really for.
    There are other ways of trying to redress the issue of hostages and possible compensation but this alert is rather pointless

    usehername and kimwy66 like this.

  9. #9

    Join Date
    Jun 2011
    Posts
    5,110
    Quote Originally Posted by HKITperson:
    Rather silly to keep this black alert as it really abuses and confuses the meaning of what a black alert is really for.
    There are other ways of trying to redress the issue of hostages and possible compensation but this alert is rather pointless
    Silly abuse of policy? That's irrelevant in the whole of scheme of things. It's politics that matter.

  10. #10

    Join Date
    Mar 2013
    Posts
    2,454
    Quote Originally Posted by Watercooler:
    Which part is ridiculous precisely? The part about being ok with keeping the black travel alert as political retribution by HK (not that it is having much impact on travelers)? Or the part where the Philippine government is giving a middle finger to the victims because Manila can afford to ignore us?

    Fact is, using policies (such as travel alerts) as political weapons is hardly unique to HK. Only the naive would think otherwise. The HK gov can claim they are doing "something" by upholding the travel alert when in fact they have done very little for the victims. Likewise, the Manila government, for their own political ends, don't apologize because they feel no pressure to do so.
    The Manila government should apologise for what exactly? Did they order the hostages to be taken or killed?

    A black alert is to warn travellers that an area is a dangerous place to visit. The Philippines it's not a dangerous place to visit and keeping it in place- whilst it is disregarded by every sane person- makes hk gov look unbelievably infantile.
    auss, kimwy66, HKITperson and 2 others like this.

Closed Thread
Page 1 of 31 1 2 3 4 9 ... LastLast