I understand the hesitation. Too many variables: age, deductible, actual coverage etc... I think comparing a plan to another is almost impossible without going into the minute details of the plan.
Just like comparing utility bills...
Cendrillon is asking very specific questions which I think are very hard to answer.
It just sounds a bit churlish to claim you have a great plan which is cheap and covers a lot then say 'na na na I'm not telling you'