Wow, wish I'd had time to catch up with this thread earlier (except then I would have spent all the time I didn't have writing inflammatory posts
).
As the thread is on the social welfare tack again, here's another tuppence worth from someone who remembers HK 25+ years ago (even then was working part time with an NGO heavily involved in both poverty relief and helping substance abusers):
It's true that government benefits here aren't as generous as in many other developed areas of the world (if you don't count health, education and the amazingly wide work of the LCSD, where we do much better than lots of "rich" countries), The other side of the coin is that a huge amount of slack is taken up by a large number of charities, large and small, which would have been red-taped out of existence elsewhere. The government also gives "passive" support by things like providing peppercorn rental leases of currently unneeded properties to those charities. The NGOs in turn, funded by private and corporate donations rather than by The Taxpayer, provide vocational skills training & other educational resources, material goods from food to white goods, subsidised or free housing/ shelter, help with utilities bills and credit problems, legal advice, and who knows what else.
Sure, there's room for more to be done, but when I compare here with places which expect the government to provide all those services, I really think HK manages amazingly well without the red tape, tax bills and layers of bureaucracy you find in Australia (the other place of which I have most experience).
Disclaimer - yes, I work for an NGO that operates from a government owned property!
And I'm aware that housing conditions here are ridiculously crowded by the standards of other countries, but I've written elsewhere of the amazing and continuing strides forwards that I've seen here over the years; blowed if I'm going to do it again here.