Mat wants to pay the last two months and doesn't get it back, I really don't have much sympathy for them. They know the game.
Last edited by jrkob; 17-11-2015 at 05:13 PM.
I really don't want to go into the details of my case but it was and still is a continuing nightmare.
PS After watching 6 series of the Walking Dead I prefer the use of foreigners to gweilos.
Join DateNov 2015Posts1
Although I couldn't say if my experience is "the norm" or "not" as I have no way to substantiate this, it is similar to @Mat 's.
In fact, had a discussion with my team mates earlier this afternoon on the floor, with those renters. People from our desk along with our HK and China sales team... all of them said they were paying their last 2 month of rent, and all of them got back their deposit. None reported a problem.
The only person who got into trouble, was me, in 1999 (posted earlier in this thread).
From my experience I lived in a country house owned by one guy and he never once paid back any deposits to all the tenants. He was notorious for it.
I let it go cause he wasn't normal and I didn't want trouble cause I moved just a few doors away, He actually after called the police three times saying I stole his property.
Just recently I rented a commercial premise and got flooded out. I found the places had illegal structures concealed under the floor and the landlord refused to fix saying it was my problem. As it was structural I couldn't fix if I wanted to. A total nut case...After sending many registered letter I found a clause in the contract and moved out at great loss.
So I love landlords
Last edited by Amypitpit; 17-11-2015 at 11:17 PM.
I was paying top money for the commercial property and had to keep a wet vacuum cleaner in the place to suck up the water. When it was not fixed I stopped something and then was told that I was not allowed to do that. (Figure) In the end the whole thing went to the courts and I had to pay for surveyor who confirmed the problem for $20000. I won the costs and that wasn't paid back so I lost that as well. Its no wonder we are now seeing empty premises popping up everywhere.
And as for going by the law... I quite agree but in my case I had to tell the various department what the laws were cause you complain and you get a letter back that never solved the problem. I.e You complain that something is wrong and you get a letter confirming it but no action so you write back and say Hey this is illegal... What you going to do?.
Last edited by Amypitpit; 18-11-2015 at 10:07 AM.
reply back to your landlord stating your agreement was witnessed and reneging on this and failure to comply will lead you to seek a small claims tribunal case against them... send a copy of that to the surveyor too as they were a party to the signed agreement and you could call them as a witness to the signed agreement. State all of this - that should quickly get the landlord to settle it or at least get the surveyor to get them to do it....
I am both tenant and landlord, and have never had either situation occur. I've been lucky with all my LL's in the past, and insofar as "final two months rent" is concerned, have also been lucky with previous tenants. (Lots of things appear to have broken under the current tenant, with repairs required left right and centre - but he's yet to leave so can't comment on the final two months).
If "we" (H.K. in general ; no specific person in mind) go around bashing Mainland China all the time for its lack of sophistication and rule of law, it's highly hypocritical for our own solution to the deposit problem to be "ditch the final two months rent". That's NOT how it should work, it's not how it's laid out in the contract, and it's certainly not the sort of moral / legal / civic behaviour we should be encouraging.
Tenants have a contractual obligation to pay rent, and per most tenancy templates used here, landlords have the right to seek recovery of such rent in addition to any associated costs of that recovery. (This whole discussion makes me think I should add an interest rate clause for future contracts!). Not paying rent would be a breach and grounds for not returning the deposit - but I still have a right to recover the rent (and associated costs), even if i'll return it back to you again afterwards. Want to pay ball? Bring it on.
If you are a good tenant and the LL screws you over the deposit, then I echo those who suggested the Small Claims Tribunal. If someone murders your friend, you let them be prosecuted, and wait for the courts to (eventually) pass a sentence. The process may be long and painful, but that's life. It doesn't give you the right to just shoot the guy yourself. Or even better, shoot him in advance.
This isn't the Minority Report.